Download IPL's Fact Sheet on The American Clean Energy and Security Act (H.R. 2454)
Interfaith Power and Light Public Policy Positions:
IPL's Clean Energy Agenda
Cap and Trade
Coal
Efficiency
Nuclear
Renewable Energy Standard
Interfaith Power and Light is working to help congregations be models of energy efficiency, utilize renewable energy, and to lead by showing a strong example of stewardship of creation. At the same time, we know that we cannot stem the tide of global warming by our actions alone, and therefore we actively support public policies to reduce society-wide U.S. emissions to a sustainable level.
IPL's Clean Energy Agenda
In February 2009, IPL delivered a petition to President Obama and Congressional leadership, signed by thousands of people of faith across the country. The petition outlined IPL's clean energy agenda:
We, the undersigned, of diverse faith traditions, stand together as brothers and sisters dedicated to
finding solutions to global warming and the threat it poses to Creation. We urge you to take swift
and meaningful action to avoid catastrophic climate change.
Global warming is a moral crisis that people of faith care deeply about. It endangers the lifesupport
systems for all that God created and puts the most vulnerable at immediate risk. It is the
world’s poor, who have contributed least to this problem, who will suffer the most.
Inaction cannot be an option. Interfaith Power and Light represents over 5,000 congregations of
all major religions throughout the country.
For the past eight years, our congregations have been
changing light bulbs, installing solar rooftops and geo-thermal systems and shrinking our carbon
footprints. We’ve shown that it can be done. But we know that our actions alone will not be
enough to stem the tide of global warming.
It is past time for the U.S. to take a leadership role in this crisis. You have thoughtfully addressed
climate change policy in your campaign and have embraced clean energy policy solutions. As
president, we ask you to enact those solutions into law.
Please act quickly to ensure the future of our planet, and of generations to come, by implementing
our clean energy agenda:
1. Make Climate Policies Equitable and Just
• Provide energy efficiency to low-income families
• Create 5 million green collar jobs
• Provide adaptation assistance to undeveloped nations
2. Green the Electricity Sector
• Move America toward a 100% clean energy future by maximizing energy efficiency,
modernizing the grid, and greatly expanding power generation from renewable energy
resources
3. Cap Emissions and Auction the Permits
• Reduce emissions by 35% below 1990 levels by 2020 and 80% by 2050
• Work with other nations to accelerate these reductions as needed to avoid further warming
beyond 2º F
• Auction 100% of credits and direct revenue to developing a massive clean energy
transition, creating green jobs, and protecting vulnerable communities
4. Clean up Transportation
• Invest in clean mass transit infrastructure, increase fuel economy standards, and develop
alternative fuels
5. Stop New Coal
• Put a moratorium on new coal-fired power plants until and unless carbon emissions can be
captured and permanently sequestered
The following are our positions on specific policies:
Capping Greenhouse Gas Emissions, Cap and Trade
IPL strongly supports a mandatory cap on emissions. Cap and Trade is a system developed to put a cost on carbon and provide market incentives for industry to lower emissions. However, putting a cost on carbon can raise energy prices, which disproportionately affects low-income people. Therefore, we advocate for a social justice element in any carbon pricing program. Such a social justice element could be an auction of emissions credits, for example, with part of the revenue from the sale of the credits earmarked for low-income households and for energy efficiency programs.
Coal
IPL opposes construction of new coal-fired power plans, whether in pulverized or liquid form.
Energy Efficiency
IPL strongly supports energy efficiency as the fastest, cheapest, and cleanest way to reduce emissions.
Nuclear
Interfaith Power and Light works to promote ethical, moral, just and sound solutions to global warming and energy needs. The urgency of the climate crisis demands a rapid transition to clean, safe, cost-effective energy sources. While nuclear power plants release no carbon dioxide, they do not currently meet these criteria.
For the following reasons, IPL does not believe building new nuclear plants presents a viable solution to global warming.
Cost and Timeline: The high cost and long time frame required to build new nuclear plants is prohibitive, given the immediacy of global warming. Energy efficiency and conservation are the fastest, cleanest, and cheapest ways to achieve significant greenhouse gas emissions reductions and this should be our first focus. Taking into account the entire life cycle of mining uranium (a nonrenewable resource) and disposing of the waste, nuclear power production is neither clean nor renewable. Investing billions of dollars (just one nuclear plant costs $14 billion) in this technology drains funds away from much more cost effective, rapidly deployable, and truly renewable alternatives, such as wind, geothermal, and solar power. (For more information on cost, please see economic studies referenced below)
Safety: Until scientists find a safe way way to deal with radioactive waste generated, building more nuclear power plants would be irresponsible to present and future generations. The link to weapons proliferation and terrorism cannot be avoided. Placing dangerous nuclear materials in the midst of our communities poses an unacceptable risk of a catastrophic event. Such an event could be a massive release of radiation due to a plant meltdown or a terrorist attack, and could kill tens of thousands of people as well as poison large areas with radioactivity for millennia.
Justice: As people of faith, we believe in justice that transcends generations, race and class. Our indigenous brothers and sisters in the US and throughout the world carry a disproportionate burden of past uranium mining legacies that pollute water and harm health. Passing on radioactive materials, with a half-life of 100,000 years, to thousands of generations to come is a profound moral failure. Even a small accident could cause the contamination of groundwater for 300,000 years.
As an additional justice issue, nuclear power plants require enormous amounts of fresh water, a precious resource whose growing scarcity will increasingly be at the heart of resource conflicts and the suffering of humans and other species.
Therefore, IPL urges a redoubled focus on energy efficiency, conservation, and renewable resources to avert the worst impacts of climate change.
Economic studies:
The Rocky Mountain Institute has conducted extensive economic analysis of the cost of nuclear compared to renewables. See: "The Nuclear Illusion" By Amory Lovins and Imran Sheikh
File Format: PDF/Adobe Acrobat
The Nuclear Policy Research Instute and the Institute for Energy and Environmental Research have published an excellent book detailing the possibilities for reaching a carbon free future without nuclear energy: Carbon Free and Nuclear Free, A Roadmap for U.S. Energy Policy by Arjun Makhijani
Taxpayers for Common Sense has documented the often overlooked and exhorbitant costs the U.S. taxpayers would be asked to absorb in the event of a nuclear accident.
Unlike no other energy source, nuclear energy is so expensive to insure that plants are essentially given subsidized insurance and a liability waiver (and have been for two generations). Liability from nuclear accidents is limited by law, shifting much of the damages to be paid by the taxpayers, or simply borne by the victims. This greatly distorts the true cost of nuclear energy, and indicates what a serious risk it poses due to catastrophic events. Taxpayers for Common Sense
Renewable Energy Standard (RES)
IPL supports a rapid ramp up of renewable energy through a national RES. Included in the definition of renewables would be sited wind, solar, geothermal and some hydro. As much as possible renewables, should be close to the source to increase efficiency. IPL supports an RES of 25% by 2015. |
